09-05-2010, 05:23 AM
12 The Geopolitics of South Asia
Quote:T he explanation of caste can take many forms. T o some it can be explained
as sui generis ââ¬â a thing unto itself ââ¬â unlike anything at other times or in other
cultures ââ¬â and therefore it can be explained by Hinduism in its own terms. For
others, it has to be explained comparatively, that it is the Indian realisation of a
form that can occur in other guises elsewhere ââ¬â and sometimes the blackââ¬âwhite
divide in the USA is quoted as a parallel. Historically we need look no further
than to Japan in the early 19th century before the Meiji R estoration to recognise
another rigid caste society ââ¬â which is still not completely erased from the cultural
record.
In Japan the ââ¬Ëproblemââ¬â¢ of untouchability still adheres to the descendants
of the untouchable (cleaners and sweepers) caste ââ¬â although it is something which
receives little publicity. Go back further in time and in Europe in the Middle Ages
there were hereditary crafts and guilds, and much further back in time unequal
citizens and slaves in Greece, and another caste system in Egypt.
Within Hinduism there is a theoretical or theological explanation of what caste
is ââ¬â although this theory is a simple and high level abstraction which often bears
little relation to caste in its practical form. T herefore, in saying the following, be
warned that I am generalising and simplifying perhaps excessively.