01-12-2004, 09:47 AM
The coming problems with the residual Indian muslim population
----------------------
As Samuel Huntington writes, internal muslim minorities are unassimilable
What India is facing the west and Israel is also facing and it will be interesting to see how it plays out
Next we have to keep in mind that thanks to demographics the problem is going to get worse with time, and Jihad is mandated when feasible
Every fork in the decision tree leads to violence and it is better to discuss it in the open
Option 1 - Do nothing
and muslims take over by reproduction and rioting and hindus get exterminated as in bangladesh
Option 2 - The other extreme
Muslims are still 13%, the same as in 1947, before the sikh-hindu reprisals
While physically this is possible, mentally hindu society is not prepared for this solution and this entails a lot of violence and counter violence
Option 3 - True secularism
Roll back to 1949
UCC, removal of article 370 etc. Sangh Parivar wants this
This involves a lot of muslim rioting since their privileges are removed
Option 4- Freeze muslim appeasement at current levels and stop further islamisation.
Hindu society seems to prefer this at this time
BJP seems to be going this route by limiting Haj to deserving candidates
The problem with this is , even if hindus freeze on current levels of muslim appeasement, muslims are not satisfied and will never be satisfied
Muslim leadership has a whole host of demands printed in Urdu press but not in
english media
Urdu press even considers the congress and CPM and the english media press as anti-muslim or not secular enough
In the Urdu press veiled threats like if these "legitimate' demands are not met
then their youth will take to violence
Read milligazette etc to get an idea into their thinking
What they want
1. End to articles about ISI and madrasas
2. Over-representation of muslims in army / police / legislature
( as in pre-partition days )
3. No action against BD illegals
4. Independence for kashmir
5. Financial aid to pakistan and BD
6. Arms licenses to all muslims
7. Ban on hindutva groups but no ban on islamist groups
8. 20% reservation for muslims and the other 80% for muslim approved hindus
9. Separate electorate
10. Separate muslim districts within each state
And a whole host of Jinnah type demands
Now even the congress cant meet these demands and at this point when their numbers reach critical mass, they will take to 'direct action'
----
Any action must be based on what at this time hindu society is willing to do
Raising hindu birth rate will stabilise the situation at option 4
----------------------
As Samuel Huntington writes, internal muslim minorities are unassimilable
What India is facing the west and Israel is also facing and it will be interesting to see how it plays out
Next we have to keep in mind that thanks to demographics the problem is going to get worse with time, and Jihad is mandated when feasible
Every fork in the decision tree leads to violence and it is better to discuss it in the open
Option 1 - Do nothing
and muslims take over by reproduction and rioting and hindus get exterminated as in bangladesh
Option 2 - The other extreme
Muslims are still 13%, the same as in 1947, before the sikh-hindu reprisals
While physically this is possible, mentally hindu society is not prepared for this solution and this entails a lot of violence and counter violence
Option 3 - True secularism
Roll back to 1949
UCC, removal of article 370 etc. Sangh Parivar wants this
This involves a lot of muslim rioting since their privileges are removed
Option 4- Freeze muslim appeasement at current levels and stop further islamisation.
Hindu society seems to prefer this at this time
BJP seems to be going this route by limiting Haj to deserving candidates
The problem with this is , even if hindus freeze on current levels of muslim appeasement, muslims are not satisfied and will never be satisfied
Muslim leadership has a whole host of demands printed in Urdu press but not in
english media
Urdu press even considers the congress and CPM and the english media press as anti-muslim or not secular enough
In the Urdu press veiled threats like if these "legitimate' demands are not met
then their youth will take to violence
Read milligazette etc to get an idea into their thinking
What they want
1. End to articles about ISI and madrasas
2. Over-representation of muslims in army / police / legislature
( as in pre-partition days )
3. No action against BD illegals
4. Independence for kashmir
5. Financial aid to pakistan and BD
6. Arms licenses to all muslims
7. Ban on hindutva groups but no ban on islamist groups
8. 20% reservation for muslims and the other 80% for muslim approved hindus
9. Separate electorate
10. Separate muslim districts within each state
And a whole host of Jinnah type demands
Now even the congress cant meet these demands and at this point when their numbers reach critical mass, they will take to 'direct action'
----
Any action must be based on what at this time hindu society is willing to do
Raising hindu birth rate will stabilise the situation at option 4