07-28-2005, 06:34 PM
Mitra you are wrong
I have census details from both Dr.Ambedkar's book
"Pakistan or the partition of India" as well as the MD.Srinivas book based on Indian census records
My numbers are based on hard facts
Your numbers are based on hearsay
I will agree, that Gopinath Bardoloi was happy to let Sylhet go to get rid of bengalis
I also agree that JN.Mandal was a Dalit stooge of jinnah
The fact is that the Jamaat-Ulema-Hind,
( Deobandis ) who were opposed to partition, ( because they wanted to islamise all of India )
swung some muslim votes to India
and India lost the referendum 47% to 53%, even though the census shows 60% muslim
G.S
I have census details from both Dr.Ambedkar's book
"Pakistan or the partition of India" as well as the MD.Srinivas book based on Indian census records
My numbers are based on hard facts
Your numbers are based on hearsay
I will agree, that Gopinath Bardoloi was happy to let Sylhet go to get rid of bengalis
I also agree that JN.Mandal was a Dalit stooge of jinnah
The fact is that the Jamaat-Ulema-Hind,
( Deobandis ) who were opposed to partition, ( because they wanted to islamise all of India )
swung some muslim votes to India
and India lost the referendum 47% to 53%, even though the census shows 60% muslim
G.S